Psychology Today blogs

Relationships Blogs  

Understanding the Dynamics of Abusive Relationships

Abusive relationships are fairly simple. They are driven by insecurity, fear that feeds that insecurity and an expectation of inconsistency, both real and perceived.

An abuser is morbidly insecure. S/he (yes, potentially, she) has little sense of his/her own social value and makes an effort to gain or re-gain some semblance of that value through domination and control. The fear that feeds that insecurity has two fronts: fear of not being lovable, and fear of appearing weak. The paradox here is that the abuser is, in fact, weak, which is why s/he abuses -- to maintain a sense of control -- in the first place. The perceived inconsistency on the part of the abuser by the victim is that the victim is not submitting to the abuser's domination.

The victim is also morbidly insecure and for surprisingly similar reasons. S/he also has little sense of his/her own social value, but makes an effort to establish that value by losing him/herself to the demand for submission. The fear that feeds this insecurity is also about not being lovable or loved, and there is a willingness to accept the inconsistency of the abuser's attention for the sake of being loved.

The pathological need to control on the part of the abuser and the pathological need for attention on the part of the victim is a match made in heaven. We are all just a bunch of neurotic habits that tend to find a fit with our opposite to create a psychosocial balance. Abusive relationships are one of the most extreme cases of this dynamic.

So, what do abusive relationships look like? Well, it's not always about being slapped around. Abusive relationships come in all forms along with physical abuse - social abuse, emotional abuse, sexual abuse (we are not referring here to molestation), financial abuse, etc. Abuse is about a dynamic of extremes, domination and submission. It is about giving and withholding, also in the extreme.

Let's look at social abuse. Have you ever had a boss who praises you one minute, and makes you wonder if you'll have a job tomorrow the next? Or let's you work yourself to the bone on a project, only to take credit or give the credit to someone else? That's an abusive dynamic. Your boss has a need to control you because s/he is threatened by you, or has a sense of insecurity about his/her own ability to motivate or lead. And you have a need for a job -- a metaphor for being loved - so you put up with it; you submit.

The abuser is also driven by a more subtle and primitive sense of fear. Because s/he is often limited in his/her social perspective, and sees things only from an egocentric perspective (i.e., has not developed a sense of ethnocentric compassion), s/he will lash out when s/he sees no other options.

The victim, on the other hand, tends to be an emotional anorexic. Starving themselves, or allowing him/herself to be starved and then gorging themselves on whatever comes his/her way only to feel guilty about it later because of a sense of not deserving what s/he has received; a state of mind that drives his/her neediness - needing, not having...having, not wanting...needing, again.

Sometimes for the victim there is also a sense of familiarity and comfort in an abusive relationship, which is why victims will often return to an abusive relationship or, leaving one, will unconsciously seek out another.

Think about growing up. Was there something that your family did that was unusual (sitting around at night, singing together or working in a community garden) that you just assumed everyone did, and you were later surprised to find that you were mistaken? It's the same thing - if you are socialized to equate love with pain or withholding, then you will seek out love in that form.

My favorite example of this is the silverware drawer. Think about where the silverware drawer was in the house in which you grew up. Now, think about where it is in your house. Allowing for architectural differences, I suspect about 90% of you will find that it's in the same place is was when you grew up. It's a memory map...why fix it, if it's not broken?

But what if you don't, or can't, recognize that it's broken? That's where we get ourselves into trouble and how we come to repeat social and relational patterns.

Abusive relationships are tricky and, just as a fish doesn't know that he's wet, we often don't see the subtle markers for abuse in a relationship because we are in it. Further, relationships fill our needs and, when our needs are being met, we don't necessarily have an imperative to take a look at how they are being met.

Here's the thing. It all comes back to us, to our responsibility and accountability. But, in this case, it comes back to responsibility to ourselves and accountability to ourselves. Instead of just riding the wave, if we choose to mindfully examine the nature of our relationships and make a determination of what is acceptable and not acceptable to us, of what feeds us, rather than bleeds us, then we are living, and loving, authentically and with mindful awareness.

© 2008 Michael J. Formica, All Rights Reserved

My Psychology Today Therapists Profile My Website
Email Me Directly Telephone Consultations

 

Comments

They said the world was flat

Michael,

If you are socialized to equate love with pain, withholding or other forms of negativity and people unconciously not only seek out those forms but find and live them, how do they break the cycle if, to them, this is what they precieve to be as normal?
If they've never reached the stage where they've realized that 'hey, not everyone sits in their house at night together and sings', then how do they ever come to realize it?
Like you say, some abuse is far less obvious than a slap across the face. How do you bring all the unconcious to the surface if you don't know to look for it? Can't you only be mindful if you are aware of negative effects?

Peace
C


Hair on fire...

The Zen Master, Taishen Deshimura Roshi said that we should, "...live every day as if our hair were on fire." What he meant was that complacency is not an option. We must live every moment with the clear vision of the diamond mind.

Awareness is not enough, we must come to a point of realization. Realization breeds action and action provokes a willingness to change. In this way we move from the knowing to the doing, from knowledge to wisdom. You are asking "...how do we get to the knowing..."

Truly, it is the same way that we come to realize that things are different than we expected. Hey -- not everyone sits around and sings every night...that was unusual... Hey -- not everyone is made to sit on the stairs with nothing to eat or drink for 10 hours straight...that was unusual.

If you are paying attention -- not being mindful, or operting with expansive awareness, or any of that gobble-dee-gook -- you will notice that things may not be what you expected them to be, and people have different experiences from which you might learn. That learning can come from anywhere -- a book, a movie, TV, a friend, even a casual conversation.

The trick is moving from, "Hey, that's different." to "Hey, I could do this differently." to "Hey, I want to do this differently." to "I will do this differently."

Blessings,
Michael


Very good article.One should

Very good article.One should always introspect and analize onself and break the habit of passively following the memory map.
Thanks,
Lipika


3 questions, first can we be both?

First, is it possible to be both an abuser and a victim within the same 2-person relationship? Second, if one is starved for emotion, even though he/she loves him/herself, how can that person obtain emotion in a healthy way, especially considering the term 'starving'? Third, isn't true that in a committed relationship, you have to take the good with the bad at times, since it can't always be good all the time, as long as it is mostly good?


Yes...

Yes, people can be both the vicitm and the abuser. Take a look at this...

http://blogs.psychologytoday.com/blog/enlightened-living/200806/sadomaso...

The use of the words starved and starving is in reference to the notion of emotionl anorexia. being starved for emotion is state of being -- being emotionally anorexic is voluntary.

Yes, there is a balance in all things, but abuse should not be part of that balance.

Blessings,
Michael


Shifting

I'll quote you: "When the underlying dynamic shifts to one of compassion, cooperation and communication from one of push and pull, the cycle ceases, or at least recedes into the background, and the stage for authentic relationship is then set." I don't think it can 'shift' on its own, can it? Is this where communication is key, by telling your partner what you would like and then hopefully obtaining cooperation? If the absence of cooperation, then what? Does one take the good with the bad, once again?


The shift...

No, the shift does not happen on its own, and it does take cooperation and communication. It does not take compromise. And in the absence of cooperation, one must decide what is acceptable and what is not, then move forward from that point. This may mean staying and dealing with the situation as it stands, this may mean staying and making changed for oneself within the context of the situation, or it may mean leaving. Every person, every situation is different, and both good and bad are relative to that person and that situation. No one is, nor should they be, a prisoner in their own life.

Blessings,
Michael


Depression is low self esteem

Are you sure you read Peter Kramer's Books! Your blaming the depressive again. Weather their a violent depressive or a passive one,or said another way,if their the controller or being controlled, they have mental problems. Depression causes psycho-motor retardation.To discuss abuse without talking about how low self esteem is created by depression is shameful. Sincerely David


Agreeing to disagree...

David:

Again, you have submitted a comment that is confusing and, frankly, apropo of nothing, as depression has no relationship to the dynamic as it is described here.

Further, there is no demonstrable causal relationship between low self-esteem and depression. There are plenty of depressives with perfectly well constituted esteem and plenty of individuals struggling with esteem issues who are not depressives. And, as I personally find the notion of self-esteem to be an incomplete construct, I question the relevance of its consideration, anyway.

In addition, while I do welcome your comments, I must admit to sometimes finding them more disruptive than helpful to the other readers, as they often appear to be agenda-driven, rather than expository -- whether that exposition be in challenge or support.

As always, thanks for your input.

Blessings,
Michael


Thank you for writing this

Thank you for writing this article. There seems to be little on this website about abusive relationships or PTSD. Being a person who is not in the field and trying to get an understanding of how adult/domestic abuse type of relationships work has been a bit of a challenge, since there is alot of simplistic or quirky information on the internet. I always appreciate analogies - they are for me ... illuminating.
Thank you


Glad to help...

And, thank you for providing me with some topic areas to which I might contribute so as to expand the content on the site.

Blessings,
Michael


Michael - You know I don't

Michael -

You know I don't read every day but I do periodically check in...

Without knowing it or having read it, I accidentally embraced your last paragraph. I simply decided that I was not willing to be so unhappy any longer. I imagine that things will change as a result of my decision; only time will tell in what direction.

Again, thanks for the excellent advise!

Eliza...


Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
eight minus eight equals
Solve this math question and enter the solution with digits. E.g. for "two plus four = ?" enter "6".

Blogger  

Find a Therapist
Choose the best match from
thousands of profiles.