Psychology Today blogs

Depression Blogs  

Would You Believe “Four Hours?”

Dr. Phillip CowenIf I prescribe an antidepressant, patients always ask, “How soon will it work?”

The standard answer, one that’s been in the literature for years, is “two weeks,” with the caveat that full effects may take weeks longer.

But clinicians have always suspected that some changes come about earlier. A (reasonably unreliable) rule of thumb is that a good, even if transient, initial response predicts a solid outcome later. And there have always been studies showing some improvement within days, so that patients are “better but not well.”

Now out of England comes research that should enter Guinness World Records.

Dr. Philip Cowen, a serotonin expert and head of the Psychopharmacology Research Unit of the Department of Psychiatry at Oxford, reports changes shortly after administering a single pill. When he gave an antidepressant to depressed patients, after four hours they were better able to pick out happy faces from a collection of images and to recall positive words from a list. Patients given a placebo showed no such change. The press release, from the Royal College of Psychiatrists, is titled "Antidepressants ‘can change the way depressed people see the world in just four hours.'" It's worth reading — won’t take you a minute.

Addendum: For a subsequent, related posting on early responses to antidepressants, see my note on treatments for premenstrual irritability

Comments

I believe it

I was on an SSRI for years and although I intially was very unoptimistic about a drug's ability to help me, I experienced a dramatic reprieve from anxiety after only a few days on Paxil. I understand that the effects may be different for depression as oppossed to anxiety, but given thier common link, it seems like the rapid effets of drugs on depression may also apply to anxiety. I believe this to be true as I have come to use anti-anxiety meds only when I need them. I am not talking about something like xanax, but an SSRI ( currently zoloft). I came to a point where I felt I did not need to take something everyday and after having a hell of a time getting off paxil I was hesitant to start another daily regimen to cope with my intermittent boughts of anxiety. My doctor prescribed zoloft, assuring me it would be easier to quit than paxil but that for it to be effective I would need to take it everyday. I I often found myself forgetting to take the zoloft for days but upon remembering, feeling calmer immediately after taking a pill. The side effects weren't there when I was not taking the pill and so now I just take one when I have a presentation coming up or another anxiety provoking situation I feel unable to handle on my own. The effects are certainly there just after a day and it's nice to not have to constantly be on medication.


---experiment

the proper experiment would not have used just SSRIs and placebo, but SSRIs, placebo, and an upper like ritalin. is it the SSRI or is it just a mood boosting chemical. for that matter how about trying alcohol.


I believe it, too

I responded to an SSRI within a few hours of my first dose. It was as if a dark cloud long overhead had suddenly begun to rapidly disperse.


How about 20 minutes?

When I first went onto Effexor, I didn't expect much -- at least not quickly. Twenty minutes (the same amount of time a Vicodin would have taken to make me spacey) later, I felt exactly that "cloud dispersion" that the previous commenter described. Absolutely, I believe it.


fast reaction? I think not.

Two words: placebo effect.


hardly.

I remember my doctor saying the same when I claimed an effect two hours after taking my first citalopram. I always found such a closed mindedness remarkable in people that were supposed to be experts. Please, take an SSRI or some MDMA and then tell me you don't feel the well known anxiolytic and mood lifting effect of a serotonine rush. whatever comes days later as result of receptor downregulation is a completely different matter.


To Anonymous

When depressives drink alcohol they actually appear more psychotic. Peter has documented in his book ''LISTENING TO PROZAC'' how stimulants also alter mood.Sincerely, DAVID


Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
plus two equals three
Solve this math question and enter the solution with digits. E.g. for "two plus four = ?" enter "6".

Blogger  

Find a Therapist
Choose the best match from
thousands of profiles.