Psychology Today blogs

Self-Help Blogs  

Stigma in Everyday Life: A Psychologist's Half Truths

Dealing with the stigma of depression is far easier in the abstract than face to face, often when we least expect it. I am a clinical psychologist and I suffer from a mood disorder. Occasionally someone will remark that these dual roles are a winning combination. But sometimes they are just the reverse.

It was a packed Sunday night at the pharmacy. My fellow procrastinators and I gathered to fill prescriptions that were perilously close to the refill deadline. I looked like I'd gotten dressed in the dark-in my husband's faded Redskin's sweatshirt, purple sweatpants and a pair of running shoes that were purchased at the inception of the NIKE brand. My hair had that "should have washed it the day before, but I just didn't feel like it" style, with sections that had clearly seceded from the overall design.

Pharmacy sections are always elevated, making me feel like a supplicant rather than a paying consumer of their products. When the pharmacist looks down from his platform, I feel like I'm petitioning the Great Oz. We procrastinators stand around rolling our eyes about the wait, grudgingly admit our culpabilty for the delay, and vigorously scan for disruptions in the rightful order of service. A voice from on high calls, "Manning." I take a few steps and admit that the name belongs to me. The pharmacist aide asks innocently, but a bit too loudly, "Do you want the Lithium in childproof or regular bottles?" Moments like these make me wish for a trap door beneath my feet in which the sheer power of mortification would trip the exit, allowing me to disappear.

People looked at me differently. Not staring exactly, but sizing me up in light of new information. Now my classification as a total slob looked less like a choice and more like a condition. People may not know exactly what Lithium is for, but most of them know that it is in the mental illness arena, and it's not good. Definitely not in the antibiotic, bunion remover or indigestion classes of medicine.

I am a clinical psychologist. I have written and spoken extensively on the stigma associated with mood disorders. I have enjoined many people to throw off the mantle of shame. I knew exactly what to say to someone else. I would tell them to march right up to the counter and demand to see the pharmacist. I would script the conversation to emphasize that the violation of my privacy was totally inappropriate. I would ask of this was standard operating procedure or a temporary lapse. And I would make them insist that it never, ever happen again.

But I couldn't do it. Because I was embarrassed. Because I was afraid that if I got angry or tearful, my behavior would be filtered through the lens of my illness, and knowledge of my diagnosis would weigh heavy in subsequent interactions. It wasn't just the Sunday night fiasco at the drug store. It happens in many places where people are well meaning, which, in some ways, makes it harder to deal with. It runs rampant on inpatient psychiatric units, where behavior that is "assertive" in other contexts may be labeled as "hostile" or "acting out."

It happened with a teeth cleaning appointment, when the dental assistant reviewed a form which required so much medical detail that I worried they'd require the date of my smallpox vaccination. She sat down next to me and said, "I'm having trouble reading some of your medicines." I should have fled the room right then, but instead I asked, which one?" I was instantly aware that the other people in the waiting room, bored to tears reading old copies of AAA magazines and Golf Digest, were interested in my story. "Now, this one," she said. SAR-OH-QUIL...what's that for?" "Sleep," I answered quickly. "Great," she said. "Now there are a few more..." With each item I responded, "Sleep...sleep...sleep." While my mind was saying, "None of your damn business," my soon to be clean mouth was spouting half-truths.

It is humbling to know how easily I can give advice, rather than take it. I do well in battling stigma in the abstract- with letters and signs and speeches. All on behalf of "other people." But it's time to do the harder work. I have to summon the courage to stand up for myself. In those difficult and not infrequent moments, I'm called to challenge the ignorance that continues to paralyze me. When it comes to facing up to stigma in my own life, I could really use a dose of my own medicine.

 

Comments

Lol funny story. Well I am a

Lol funny story. Well I am a psychology student and I am kind of bipolar more on the depresses side but I am not ashamed nor proud of my "condition".

If I would have the impression of her "revealing" me, than I would have told her:" Yeah lithium!" Extra loud with a evil smile on my face. On the other hand the best reaction is like it's no big deal. Well I guess I don't care that much what I believe other people may think lol

Best healing for the embarresment problem: Go out and tell everyone that you suffer clinical depression. Guess what, no one cares haha


The nonsense of prejudice...

I've always been regrettably dismayed that what is a simple organic disorder, no more or less systemically disruptive than say, diabetes, meets with such egregious social stigma.

In some ways, as a culture, we still respond with a rather medieval mindset when it comes to anything remotely suggesting mental illness.

It's all quite silly, really, but smacks of the hostility and lack of compassion that is generally the response to situations that people don't understand or of which they feel intolerant.

Blessings,
Michael


I can relate...

...as a professional mental health therapist I suffer from GAD issues. I have all sorts of manuals and workbooks on anxiety and am constantly stressing the usefulness of the various excercises in them to my clients but do I ever use any of these myself...unfortunately...very rarely!

Aaron


With you on this...

I get what you mean. I just sort of outed myself on my blog (Ninth Elegy) about my dysthymia and then again in a book that was just published, where I told a gut-wrenching story of complicated grief about my father's death from alcohol, and my convoluted healing process, revealing a lot of difficult and yucky feelings. I now feel so vulnerable that it's hard for me to want to tell people about the book--especially clients! But I remind myself, it's important to be brave and tell our stories, because in reading your story I feel encouraged. When I see you doing it, I think, "Wow, she's really courageous and honest!" When I do it myself, I think, "what am I thinking??" That's just my shame talking. Thanks for being so courageous and honest, because I really do, deep down, think this leveling of our own issues is what truly helps others.


Uhmm...

Laurel:

Shut up -- you're brave as hell.

Blessings,
Michael


Thanks for personal insight

I don't have depression but enjoy learning about it. Thanks for sharing-Sincerely David


Stigma

I have a mood disorder and have had a pharmacist (assistant) ask me a question a bit too loudly about my prescription of lithium and I did not stand up for myself or say anthing about the fact that I was embarrassed because there was a customer standing right next to me; heard the pharmacist and the customer looked directly at me; Pharmacist should already know and be trained not to discuss a person's medication in front of anyone or where anyone could hear;

There is definitely a stigma about being on lithium and I am afraid or ashamed to even tell my best friends especially anyone I work with; I did make the mistake of saying something to a coworker about taking trazadone because she is taking it also but she doesn't have enough common sense to keep it quiet; Also she goes to the same nurse practitioner as I do and discussed the fact that we work together with the nurse practitioner which I think is very unprofessional and unethical; Then the coworker blabs very loudly in the office that she had been to see the nurse and mentioned my name - People should realize that these things are very confidential!!!


Confidential

Unfortunately, when the person talking about your medical issues is not in the medical field, that they are not breaching confidentiality. If your nurse discussed you with the coworker (rather than just the coworker talking about you) then he/she would have broken confidentiality. We have to be careful what we disclose to people outside the medical field as they have no obligation to keep it to themselves and although it is wrong, that doesn't make them unethical, just uncaring and obtuse.


HEPA and our privacy

I've had the same happen on two occasions. Both times I asked the Pharmacist's assistant if she wouldn't like to repete the question a little louder so everyone in the store could hear her.

I too take meds for depression. I also take an anti-seizure medicine for migrains. It is not in my nature to stand up for myself, but in both instances I was so embarassed I just blurted it out.

With the new HEPA laws inacted, everyone in the medical field has to be very careful about our privacy. Hurray for HEPA.


Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
ten plus ten equals
Solve this math question and enter the solution with digits. E.g. for "two plus four = ?" enter "6".

Blogger  

Martha Manning's Recent Posts  

Find a Therapist
Choose the best match from
thousands of profiles.