Psychology Today blogs

Gender Blogs  

Fantasy Weddings Can Hurt More Than Your Wallet

Brides-to-be are told they are allowed to be a princess for day. Besides making a dent in the bridal pocketbook, does wanting to be a princess undermine women’s power?

Marriage in this country might be about a man and a woman, but planning a wedding is really about the bride. This is more than just tradition—it’s a capitalist driven idea that has managed to create a huge economic windfall for wedding vendors. It’s a fact that as the divorce rate has continued the increase, the annual cost of an American wedding has also increased. The estimated average cost ranges from $19,000 - $30,000.

Now the price wouldn’t bother me so much if it wasn’t laced with so much fairytale propaganda. Advertisers are no dummies, and they know how to make even the most secure woman feel cheap for not wanting to spend more than $1,000 on a dress she’ll wear only once in her lifetime.

A casual flip through a bridal magazine found me face to face with an ad in which a young bride-to-be was sitting on a throne in a shaded forest. In front of her, down one knee, was her groom, or rather “prince charming” by the way he was dressed. The ad was brilliant because it captured just what advertisers would love for women to believe – that a wedding is a temporary suspension of disbelief in fairytales and that a bride is in fact a princess. After all, princesses are unlikely to be found shopping in the bargain bin.

And what’s wrong with that you might ask? Besides unloading your hard-earned cash, is there any real problem with the idea that a bride ought to be treated like a princess? Is there really any harm for wanting to be Cinderella for a day?

I recently came across a study that attempted to provide a partial answer to these questions. Dr. Laurie Rudman at Rutgers University was interested in finding out the effects of romantic fantasies on women’s psyches. She measured women’s implicit, i.e. subconscious, endorsement of romantic fantasies. She also measured their conscious endorsement of the same romantic fantasies, i.e. how much they actually said they believed in them. Rudman’s first finding was that there was a large divergence between what women reported desiring and their subconscious feelings.

Her second finding was that only women’s subconscious endorsement of romantic fantasies predicted their interest in achieving personal power. Women who subconsciously endorsed romantic fantasies reported a lower desire for personal power.

It’s only one study, I know, but I offer it as some food for thought as to the effect of romantic fantasies on women. A desire for personal power need not be exploitive – it could also denote a desire to achieve, to lead, or to make an impact on others.

Regardless of their possible negative effects, romantic fantasies aren’t going away. Not only do they make for good movie plotlines, they are something that society – especially advertisers – would hate to lose.

Source: Rudman, L. A. & Heppen, J. (2003). Implicit romantic fantasies and women's interest in personal power: A glass slipper effect? Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 29, 1357-1370.

Comments

I have to agree with the

I have to agree with the blogger on many points. I cringe when I hear of elaborate weddings. The burden on our earth's resouces is enormous and I wonder if we can afford it at this time when we are facing global warming.
Marriage ceremony has been traditionaly held for family and friends to witness a union. It signified to the world that the couple will now live their life as a family unit. The high divorce rate shows that the union is not as binding anymore as it used to be. Nina


Then what should it be

I understand that this is a million dollar industry. The industry of selling weddings to brides. But my question is what is the alternative. Marriage has always involved money. Perhaps it is better that all the money has gone to private firms instead of the groom as dowry. Our very being is based on industry now. Even Death is a million dollar industry(Is there a magazine about funerals?).
Furthermore, this industry has gotten the bride involved in the process. It has empowered her to choose a perfect wedding. Perhaps it is not good for a society when the wife does seek personal power. She should put her family first because she is now the queen of her kingdom. So many times liberals want to take away the old ways. You asked the question what is wrong about a women trying to be a princess for the day. I still fail to see what is wrong with that image. Must we take away everything from people. The utopia that we seek when men and women are equal can only lead to a bleak black and white society.


Alternatives

Dr. Carter,

Thanks for posting your thoughts. I think some advertisers have already thought of alternatives and as society keeps changing, the industry will adapt. For example, with the rising number of divorces there is reportedly a growing trend to have "divorce parties" -- and cater to that growing segment.

I think there are plenty of people who are also choosing alternatives to the traditionally wasteful wedding industry. I've witnessed several couples who have chosen to do buck certain trends. My brother recently got married and he and his fiancee included a card in their invitation inviting guests to donate money to charities of the couples' choosing.

Daisy


Even death is a million dollar industry

This may a bit off-topic, but has anybody read the latest issue of Mortuary Management magazine? There are some wonderful articles about the funeral industry.

http://www.abbottandhast.com/mmcurrent.html


Oh, for Princess' sakes...

Regardless of the coincidental correlation of the divorce rate to high-priced weddings, I think it is less that a woman wants to feel special but that a good majority are immature to begin with. Most "bridezillas" are young women who just want all the attention placed on them for a day--they don't think that once the 1000.00 cake is eaten and the myriad of presents are opened that the effortless part of the fairytale is over. Prince Charming has to go slog away at a (likely) low-end job so they have enough money for her to get her nails done. Disillusionment sets in fairly quickly afterwards and she begins looking for her next attention-grabbing party--a baby shower, perhaps??
The unfortunate end is alarmingly not only broken vows but broken families as well. So much for happily-ever-after...


entitlement

I see nothing wrong with wanting to feel extra special for a day, but feeling entitled to this at any cost is a disturbing trend. My ex sister-in-law just had her second wedding and it was more elaborate than the first. She registered for everything again, not five years later) and dropped a fortune on yet another extravagent reception. What should have been a celebration of finding another love with the potential to last a lifetime turned into an excuse to be the center of attention.

A first wedding may be a mix of celebrating the love and having a traditional experience with the whole wedding showcase. I get wanting to have that once in your life and why not combine it with a happy event? A second marriage, however, should really just focus on the relationship itself. If you have already been married you should know more than anyone that the party is just a party. I question anyone who wants such a charade again and again. If I get married again it will be a small intimate affair and the fairytale will be a chance to build a life with someone not one more day of "look at me."


If you're not a princess, you're a freak!

Sadly, if you choose to buck wedding traditions then it is extremely hard to navigate the wedding industry; not to mention people that don't know you well (or do, sadly) will think you're a freak.

My wedding budget is $2500, and I'm honestly hoping to keep it under $1500 (this includes the dress and the tux and the EVERYTHING). Whenever I do anything wedding related that involves anyone outside of my immediate circle, I tend to get blank stares and uncertainty.

No, we don't have a color scheme; no, we're not having bridesmaids or best men; no, we're not particularly set on a date or a time; no, we're not sending invitations; no, we're not going on a honeymoon; no, we're not having bachelor or bachelorette parties/rehearsal dinner/engagement party.

We're so conditioned to what is 'normal' behavior for a bride that anyone who doesn't conform to that is an abnormal woman, an abnormal bride, and an abnormal wife. People understand bridezillas, people accept elopements, people have no concept for anything in the middle.


Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
eight minus zero equals
Solve this math question and enter the solution with digits. E.g. for "two plus four = ?" enter "6".

Blogger  

Find a Therapist
Choose the best match from
thousands of profiles.